Here is an interesting (draft) paper about Social Network structures in the Isabelle and Coq community, based on the main mailing lists of the two systems:
J. Fleuriot, S. Obua, Ph. Scott: Social Network Processes in the Isabelle and Coq Theorem Proving Communities. arXiv:1609.07127, September 2016.
Just a few comments of mine:
Microsoft is more and more becoming an Open Source company, e.g. it has joined the Linux foundation as Platinum member in November 2016. A notable Open Source project by Microsoft is Visual Studio Code: under the slogans “Code editing. Redefined. Free. Open Source. Runs everywhere.” it provides a very interesting editor framework, as a desktop application based on Node.js and TypeScript.
The prover community has already started to support this emerging successor of vi and Emacs, e.g. see Coq Support for Visual Studio Code and the Lean for VSCode.
Isabelle/VSCode is now following this trend: I have spent some weeks in December 2016 / January 2017 with VSCode, using a little bit of TypeScript and implementing the new Language Server Protocol in Isabelle/Scala. The subsequent screenshot shows formal annotations produced by Isabelle/PIDE in the usual manner, while the editor rendering is all done by VSCode. For more information, see the report Isabelle/VSCode in January 2017.
The Isabelle/VSCode project was funded by Aesthetic Integration (AI). See also my article about a talk at ITP 2016 by Grant Passmore (co-founder of AI).
Another Isabelle presentation at Curry Club Augsburg (01-Dec-2016) has been recorded and uploaded to Youtube.
See also the original announcement.
On Thu 01-Dec-2016 there will be a presentation about “Foundations of Higher-Order Logic with Classical Reasoning and Hilbert-Choice” at Curry Club Augsburg.
Start: approximately 19:00
Duration: approximately 90min
Language of the talk: German
- History of Higher-Order Logic
- Implementations of HOL
- Quasi-programming in Isabelle/HOL
- Isabelle foundations: primitive inferences, object-logic rules, rule composition, structured proofs
- Foundations of Higher-Order Logic: actual Isabelle/HOL, Pure bootstrap of HOL
Isabelle theory with some exercises (for Isabelle2016-1)
The coming Isabelle2016-1 release is scheduled for December 2016. This spot is continuously updated to inform about the ongoing process of testing release candidates.
- On 07-Oct-2016 an informal snapshot Isabelle2016-1-RC0 was published.
- On 28-Oct-2016 the release candidate Isabelle2016-1-RC1 was published. Serious testing by users is now required, to expose remaining problems.
- On 06-Nov-2016 the release candidate Isabelle2016-1-RC2 was published. Various details have been consolidated.
- On 22-Nov-2016 the release candidate Isabelle2016-1-RC3 was published. More fine points have been consolidated. A component for the new experimental Nunchaku tool has been included.
- On 27-Nov-2016 the release candidate Isabelle2016-1-RC4 was published. It introduces the following important last-minute changes:
- Prover IDE: more aggressive flushing of machine-generated input
- Sledgehammer: MaSh is faster and less likely to hang seemingly forever
- fine-tuning of Isabelle/LaTeX typesetting
- On 08-Dec-2016 the release candidate Isabelle2016-1-RC5 was published, presumably the last one. It introduces the following important last-minute changes:
- more uniform automatic indentation (empty vs. non-empty lines)
- fewer tracing/warning messages in some proof tools
The Isabelle release process is subject to the laws of causality: release candidates can be modified, but the final release remains final. Testing needs to happen in the weeks before the final release, not after it.
The main forum for discussion of Isabelle2016-1 release candidates is on isabelle-users mailing list.
Update 13-Dec-2016: The final release of Isabelle2016-1 (December 2016) is now available from the Isabelle website. The above release candidates will disappear eventually.
On Friday 18-Nov-2016 10:00, I will give a presentation about PIDE at Laboratoire de Recherche en Informatique, Orsay (Paris Sud).
Isabelle is usually positioned as environment for interactive and automated theorem proving, but its Prover IDE (PIDE) may be used for regular program development as well. Standard ML is particularly important here, since it is the bootstrap language of Isabelle/ML (i.e. SML with many add-ons) and Isabelle/Pure (i.e. the logical framework).
The ML IDE functionality of Isabelle + Poly/ML is manifold:
- Continuous feedback from static analysis and semantic evaluation is already available for years, e.g. Isabelle2014 (August 2014). It is a corollary of how PIDE interaction works, and of the integration of the Poly/ML compiler into that framework. Source files are statically checked and semantically evaluated while the user is editing. The annotated sources contain markup about inferred types, references to defining positions of items etc.
- Source-level debugging within the IDE is new in Poly/ML 5.6, which is bundled with Isabelle2016 (February 2016). The Prover IDE provides the Debugger dockable to connect to running ML threads, inspect the stack frame with local ML bindings, and evaluate ML expressions in a particular run-time context. See also here.
- IDE support for the Isabelle/Pure bootstrap process is new technology for the coming release of Isabelle2016-1 (December 2016). The ROOT.ML file acts like a quasi-theory in the context of theory ML_Bootstrap: this allows continuous checking of all loaded ML files. The theory file is presented with a modified header to import Pure from the running Isabelle instance.
It is also possible to modify standalone SML projects, to edit the sources freely in the ML IDE. For example, MetiTarski can participate after some trivial changes of its ROOT.ML file.
Overall, we move more and more to an integrated framework for development of formal-reasoning tools, but other applications are admissible as well.
The Slides are available, together with their sources (which are required for the live system demo).
On Tuesday 15-Nov-2016 14:00, I will give a presentation about PIDE at Laboratoire Spécification et Vérification, Cachan (Paris). See also the official announcement.
Interactive theorem proving was historically tied to the read-eval-print loop, with sequential and synchronous evaluation of prover commands given on the command-line. This user-interface technology was adequate when Robin Milner introduced his LCF proof assistant in the 1970s, but today it severely restricts the potential of multicore hardware and advanced IDE front-ends.
The Isabelle Prover IDE breaks this loop and retrofits the read-eval-print phases into an asynchronous model of document-oriented proof processing. Instead of feeding a sequence of commands into the prover process, the primary interface works via edits over immutable document versions. Execution is implicit and managed by the prover in a timeless and stateless manner, making adequate use of parallel hardware.
PIDE document content consists of the theory sources (with dependencies via theory imports), and auxiliary source files of arbitrary user-defined format: this allows to integrate other languages than Isabelle/Isar into the IDE. A notable application is the Isabelle/ML IDE, which can be also applied to the system itself, to support interactive bootstrapping of the Isabelle/Pure implementation.
Further tool integration works via “asynchronous print functions” that operate on already checked theory sources. Thus long-running or potentially non-terminating processes may provide spontaneous feedback while the user is editing. Applications range from traditional proof state output (which often consumes substantial run-time) to automated provers and dis-provers that report on existing proof document content (e.g. Sledgehammer, Nitpick, Quickcheck in Isabelle/HOL). It is also possible to integrate “query operations” via additional GUI panels with separate input and output (e.g. for manual Sledgehammer invocation or find-theorems).
Thus the Prover IDE orchestrates a suite of tools that help the user to write proofs. In particular, the classic distinction of ATP and ITP is overcome in this emerging paradigm of Integrated Theorem Proving.
The Slides are available.
At the Isabelle Workshop 2016 in Nancy, I presented Isabelle/PIDE as IDE for ML. See also the outline of the main concepts and examples, together with the full demo setup.
At the Isabelle Workshop 2016 in Nancy, I presented a paper about recent renovations of the Isar proof language:
This is a description of the Isar proof language as it stands today in 2016. This means the official release Isabelle2016 (February 2016), and the next release that is presumably published towards the end of the year. Relevant NEWS entries and updated portions from the Isabelle/Isar Reference Manual are summarized in one comprehensive article.
See also the full paper and the slides.
Another Isabelle presentation at Curry Club Augsburg (19-May-2016) has been recorded and uploaded to Youtube.
Materials from the presentation:
- Exercise from Haskell Workshop 1 + 2 (Dec-2015).
- Solution produced during the presentation.
- Slides that were briefly shown towards the end.
To try it interactively (with Prover IDE markup), it is possible to open the URL of the Solution directly in Isabelle/jEdit.