All posts by Makarius

Isabelle/VSCode and the Language Server Protocol at Curry Club Augsburg

Here is the video for my presentation at Curry Club Augsburg (09-Aug-2018) about Isabelle/VSCode and the Language Server Protocol:

The PDF Slides (including important links) are also available.

Slides for presentations at FLoC 2018 (Oxford)

The slides for my presentations at FLoC 2018 (Oxford) are now available via the official “smart slide” service:

Video for Isabelle/PIDE presentation at Curry Club Augsburg

Here is the video for the Isabelle/PIDE presentation at Curry Club Augsburg from 14-Jun-2018:

There are some technical challenges: missing screen recording in the first 25min, and occasional changes in the speed of screen recording later on: sometimes the computer screen is ahead of the talk. Nonetheless, this is an opportunity to learn many things about Isabelle/PIDE, how it is done, why it is done like that.

Isabelle/jEdit as Formal IDE at Curry Club Augsburg

On Thu 14-Jun-2018 I will talk about Isabelle/jEdit as Formal IDE at Curry Club Augsburg.

Start: approximately 19:00.
Duration: undefined.
Language of the talk: German
Slides: PDF

This is a spin-off from the paper that I will present at the F-IDE workshop on Sat 14-Jul-2018 in Oxford.

Release candidates for Isabelle2018

We are heading towards the Isabelle2018 release, which is scheduled for August 2018. This spot provides a reference for upcoming release candidates.

  • Isabelle2018-RC0 (06-Jun-2018): informal snapshot for experimentation. See also AFP/7f9c8aca53e8.
  • Isabelle2018-RC1 (02-Jul-2018): first official release candidate; almost everything ready, but some documentation still needs update. See also AFP/2af750da996c.
  • Isabelle2018-RC2 (22-Jul-2018): consolidated release candidate (after attending FLoC 2018 at Oxford). See also AFP/7175b64d54a4. Notable changes:
    • Update of Poly/ML component: slightly improved performance and more robust.
    • Update of Kodkodi component for Nitpick on Windows (back to status-quo from Isabelle2017).
    • Session HOL-Real_Asymp by Manuel Eberl.
    • Further library tuning of HOL, HOL-Analysis, HOL-Algebra.
  • Isabelle2018-RC3 (29-Jul-2018): fairly stable release candidate. See also AFP for Isabelle2018. Notable changes:
    • Update of Poly/ML component: proper monitoring of ML threads.
    • Update to latest Java 8 release: jdk-8u181.
    • More command-line options for isabelle vscode_server (relevant for VSCode settings isabelle.args).
    • Isabelle Server: allow to specify timeout for use_theories.
    • Proper treatment of forked proof within context of subgoal premises.
    • More robust build of HOL-Proofs with threads=2.
    • More flexible document build script.
    • Clarified word characters in Isabelle/jEdit to accommodate \<^control> symbols.
  • Isabelle2018-RC4 (07-Aug-2018): presumably the last release candidate. See also AFP for Isabelle2018. Notable changes:
    • Update of Isabelle/jEdit manual.
    • Fine-tuning of isabelle build options -c -x -B.
    • Fine-tuning of Isar command span range: relevant for checking of formal comments.
    • Removed Sledgehammer prover veriT: not ready for release.

The Isabelle release process is subject to the laws of causality: release candidates can be modified, but the final release is unchangeable. This means that testing needs to happen in the weeks before the final release.

The main forum for discussion of Isabelle2018 release candidates is on isabelle-users mailing list.

Jugend forscht: Hilbert meets Isabelle

A group of smart students from Bremen have been working on a formalization of Hilbert’s 10th Problem (DPRM Theorem) in Isabelle since October 2017. See also the forthcoming presentation on the Isabelle Workshop 2018 (13-Jul-2018, Oxford, UK) with the following pre-print paper.

A subgroup of particularly young students have also submitted their contribution to the project in the German science competition “Jugend forscht”, and have now won various prizes, notably the “Prize for Extraordinary Work” by Federal President of Germany, Frank-Walter Steinmeier. The catalog of winners lists the project on page 4, with the following laudatio:

Die Jury war begeistert von der Tiefe und begrifflichen Präzision, mit der sich die drei Jungforscher dem komplexen Thema des formalen Verifizierens annahmen. Formale Verifikation ist ein hochaktuelles und wichtiges Thema. Die anspruchsvolle und außergewöhnliche Forschungsarbeit leistet einen wichtigen Beitrag, die Fundamente der Mathematik noch ein Stück stabiler zu machen.

The jury was enthusiastic about the depth and conceptual precision with which the three young researchers addressed the complex topic of formal verification. Formal verification is a highly topical and important topic. The demanding and extraordinary research work makes an important contribution to making the foundations of mathematics even more stable.
(Translated with

There are some sources and presentation materials on GitLab.

The Isabelle community is looking forward to the final completion of the formalization!

Isabelle/jEdit as formal IDE

This is my contribution to the F-IDE workshop (14-Jul-2018, Oxford, UK): Isabelle/jEdit as IDE for domain-specific formal languages and informal text documents.


Isabelle/jEdit is the main application of the Prover IDE (PIDE) framework and the default user-interface of Isabelle, but it is not limited to theorem proving. This paper explores possibilities to use it as a general IDE for formal languages that are defined in user-space, and embedded into informal text documents. It covers overall document structure with auxiliary files and document antiquotations, formal text delimiters and markers for interpretation (via control symbols). The ultimate question behind this: How far can we stretch a plain text editor like jEdit in order to support semantic text processing, with support by the underlying PIDE framework?

The Isabelle Server: responsive control of prover sessions

Recent Isabelle repository versions (e.g. 83902fff6243 as approximation of Isabelle2018) support client-server connections for Isabelle prover sessions, with a
simple line-based protocol for synchronous commands. Asynchronous tasks work by explicit indication of forked vs. finished (or failed) background processes, potentially with intermediate notifications. Protocol messages use JSON syntax by default, but YXML is also possible (e.g. for native PIDE messages that might be supported in the future).

Further details are explained in chapter 4 of the system manual, e.g. see the Documentation panel in Isabelle/jEdit of a recent release snapshot. Here is a minimal example extracted from the manual:

isabelle server &
isabelle client
session_start {"session": "HOL"}
use_theories {"session_id": ..., "theories": ["~~/src/HOL/ex/Seq"]}
session_stop {"session_id": ...}

The first two commands are for the Unix terminal, the rest for the Isabelle client-server loop. Each line needs to be applied carefully, when the previous command has finished, and use_theories needs to fit on a single line.

Under program control, explicit messages for forked and finished tasks (with unique id) may be used to enforce execution in the proper order.

Update 12-Jul-2018: Link to forthcoming Isabelle2018.

Bitcoin, das Zahlungsmittel der Zukunft? Was ist dran am Bitcoin-Hype?

Die Internationale Kelleruni Herrenbach veranstaltet im April eine öffentliche Vorlesung über Bitcoin und Blockchain.

Bitcoin, das Zahlungsmittel der Zukunft? Was ist dran am Bitcoin-Hype?
Dr. Makarius Wenzel
Autor Christoph Ulrich Mayer
Freitag, 13. April 2018 um 19:30
Lebensraum Schwabencenter (“Wohnzimmer”)

Das “Wohnzimmer” im Schwabencenter ist ein umgenutztes Ladenlokal innerhalb des regulären Einkaufszentrums. Nach der Vorlesung gibt es noch etwas zu Essen.

Peter Biet von der Kelleruni schreibt hierzu:

Ich selber bin auf diese Vorlesung sehr gespannt, denn ich lese davon ständig in der Zeitung. Ich höre von vielen gerade jungen Menschen, die relativ große Summen in Bitcoins investieren und damit dann auch tatsächlich “richtig Kohle” machen. Ich höre von der Möglichkeit, Geldflüsse unabhängig von Banken zu inszenieren, aber auch von Schwarzgeldern, die da gewaschen werden. Ich höre außerdem von den riesigen Rechnerleistungen, die benötigt werden, um Bitcoins zu schürfen. Und vor allem weiß ich Eines: Ich verstehe das Ganze überhaupt nicht. Finde, obwohl ich versucht habe, mich zu informieren einfach keinen Zugang zu der Sache.
Vielleicht geht es manchen von euch ja genau so. Jedenfalls bin ich des Öfteren gebeten worden, dass wir uns mal dieses so aktuellen Themas annehmen sollten. Und so freue ich mich sehr und bin gewiss, dass Makarius und Christoph da etwas Licht in mein/unser Wissensdunkel bringen werden.

Hier das Material von Makarius.

Further Scaling of Isabelle Technology

On Monday 05-Feb-2018, I will give a presentation about Further Scaling of Isabelle Technology at VU Amsterdam, invited by Jasmin Christian Blanchette. See also the official seminar website.


Over 32 years, Isabelle has made a long way from a small experimental proof assistant to a versatile platform for proof document development and maintenance. There has always been a challenge to keep up with the natural growth of applications, notably the Archive of Formal Proofs (AFP).

  • Can we scale this technology further, towards really big libraries of formalized mathematics?
  • Can the underlying Scala/JVM and Poly/ML platforms cope with the demands?
  • Can we eventually do 10 times more and better?

I will revisit these questions from the perspectives of

  1. Editing: Prover IDE,
  2. Building: batch-mode tools and background services,
  3. Browsing: HTML views and client-server applications.